When to Refinance a Mortgage: What the CFPB Says to Compare
The CFPB frames a refinance as a comparison: what a new mortgage costs against what it is meant to achieve. This page quotes the CFPB handout and key terms in full, and works through one example of dividing closing costs by the monthly saving.
Maintained by Archie Chang · Sources checked November 15, 2026 · Methodology & sources
Quick answer
The CFPB handout lists four situations in which it might not make sense to refinance: planning to move soon, a home whose value has fallen, a credit standing that has declined, and a prepayment penalty on the current mortgage. It says to weigh the costs of a new mortgage, shown on the Loan Estimate, against your goals. In the example below (a $250,000 balance over 30 years, 7.00% against 6.00%, $5,000 of closing costs, all example numbers and not market rates) principal and interest falls by $164.38 a month, so the costs divided by that saving come to 30.4 months.
What the CFPB says refinancing is
“Refinancing happens when you pay off your current mortgage with money from a new mortgage. Often homeowners refinance to try to lower the cost of their mortgage.”
“Mortgage refinance is when you take out a new loan to pay off and replace your old loan. Common reasons to refinance are to lower the monthly interest rate, lower the mortgage payment, or to borrow additional money. When you refinance, you usually have to pay closing costs and fees. If you refinance and get a lower monthly payment, make sure you understand how much of the reduction is from a lower interest rate and how much is because your loan term is longer.”
The CFPB’s questions to ask first
The CFPB handout gives a list of situations to check before refinancing:
“If you check any of these boxes, it might not make sense to refinance your mortgage.”
“Are you planning to move soon? If you know you’re going to move in the next few years, you might not have time to recoup the cost of refinancing.”
“Has the value of your home fallen? If the market value of your home is lower now than when you took your original mortgage, it may be harder to find a refinancing loan that is more favorable than your current loan. Homeowners who have money available to pay down their loan may find better options for refinancing.”
“Has your credit standing declined? Your credit score affects the cost of your loan. If your score has fallen, review the interest rate and other terms you are offered to be sure the loan is still a good deal.”
“Does your mortgage have a prepayment penalty? Check your loan documents to see if your mortgage has a prepayment penalty. If so, you have to pay the penalty if you refinance your mortgage.”
Those are the handout’s four questions, all quoted above. For how prepayment penalties work and what Regulation Z says about them, see how to pay off a mortgage faster.
Costs against goals
“If you are ready to consider a refinance, you can start by weighing the costs of a new mortgage against your goals for refinancing. When you ask a lender for a refinance, you receive a Loan Estimate that shows all the features of the loan, including whether there is a prepayment penalty, as well as the total dollar cost of the loan.”
The handout describes three common goals and what each can do to the payment and the total:
“When you refinance to lower your interest rate, you are signing up for a new loan with a new loan term, which could be longer. That could mean a lower monthly payment, but paying more money in total.”
“Through refinancing, you could choose to shorten the term of your loan. This can mean paying off the loan faster, and paying less total interest, but your monthly payment could be higher.”
“Refinancing from an adjustable-rate to a fixed-rate mortgage can mean a higher monthly payment, but with more certainty in the future. Your principal and interest payments do not change with a fixed-rate loan, but can change a lot with an adjustable-rate loan.”
Recouping closing costs: closing costs divided by the monthly saving
The CFPB speaks of recouping the cost of refinancing. One way to put a number on it is to divide the closing costs by how much the principal and interest payment falls. This is arithmetic on example numbers, not a CFPB figure and not a market rate. It keeps the same balance and the same 30-year term at both rates, so it leaves out the longer-term effect the CFPB describes above.
| Example input or result | Amount |
|---|---|
| Balance and term | $250,000 over 30 years |
| Current rate and monthly principal and interest | 7.00%, $1,663.26 |
| New rate and monthly principal and interest | 6.00%, $1,498.88 |
| Monthly saving in principal and interest | $164.38 |
| Closing costs (example) | $5,000 |
| Closing costs divided by the monthly saving | 30.4 months (31 payments) |
The monthly payments come from the same payment formula as the mortgage calculator. To enter your own figures, use the refinance break-even calculator, the mortgage rate change savings calculator or, for a lump-sum payment instead of a new loan, the mortgage recast calculator.
Frequently asked questions
When should you refinance a mortgage?
The CFPB texts quoted on this page give no rate difference or percentage that makes a refinance worthwhile. The handout says: “If you check any of these boxes, it might not make sense to refinance your mortgage.” and lists four questions, among them: “Are you planning to move soon? If you know you’re going to move in the next few years, you might not have time to recoup the cost of refinancing.” It says to weigh the costs of a new mortgage against your goals for refinancing.
How do you work out how long it takes to recoup refinance closing costs?
The CFPB speaks of recouping the cost of refinancing. The arithmetic divides the closing costs by the monthly saving in principal and interest. In the example on this page, $5,000 divided by $164.38 is 30.4 months. The division ignores a longer new loan term, which the CFPB says could mean paying more money in total.
What does it cost to refinance a mortgage?
The CFPB key terms say: “Mortgage refinance is when you take out a new loan to pay off and replace your old loan. Common reasons to refinance are to lower the monthly interest rate, lower the mortgage payment, or to borrow additional money. When you refinance, you usually have to pay closing costs and fees. If you refinance and get a lower monthly payment, make sure you understand how much of the reduction is from a lower interest rate and how much is because your loan term is longer.” The handout adds that the Loan Estimate shows the total dollar cost of the loan.
Does a prepayment penalty matter when refinancing?
The CFPB handout says: “Does your mortgage have a prepayment penalty? Check your loan documents to see if your mortgage has a prepayment penalty. If so, you have to pay the penalty if you refinance your mortgage.” The rules on prepayment penalties are quoted on the page about paying off a mortgage faster (12 CFR 1026.43(g)).
Related pages
Sources (checked November 15, 2026): CFPB: Should I refinance? (handout) · CFPB: Mortgages key terms