Debt Payoff Calculator: Avalanche, Snowball and Consolidation Compared
This debt calculator takes each debt’s balance, APR and minimum payment, adds an extra monthly amount, and shows months to payoff and total interest for the avalanche and snowball orders side by side, next to a debt consolidation loan comparison. It reports arithmetic outcomes only and does not recommend either order.
Maintained by Archie Chang · Sources checked November 15, 2026 · Methodology & sources
Quick answer
With the example debts below ($17,500.00 in total, $375.00 in minimum payments and $200.00 extra a month), paying in avalanche order (highest APR first) takes 40 months and $5,230.41 of interest, and paying in snowball order (smallest balance first) takes 43 months and $7,043.97 of interest. A consolidation loan with the example terms (12% APR, 60 months, 3% origination fee added to the loan) has a payment of $400.96 a month and $6,032.37 of interest, plus a $525.00 fee. Change any box to see your own numbers.
Your debts
The values in the boxes are examples to show how the calculator works. They are not market rates or a quote. Replace each one with your own figure.
Everything runs in your browser and nothing you enter is sent anywhere or stored. FedRateCalc is not a lender, does not take loan applications and does not give financial advice; results are estimates, not a loan offer.
Side by side
Debt 2: the minimum payment of $180.00 does not exceed its first month's interest of $180.00, so on its own that balance never pays down.
| Measure | Avalanche (highest APR first) | Snowball (smallest balance first) | Consolidation loan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | $575.00 | $575.00 | $400.96 |
| Months to payoff | 40 months | 43 months | 60 months |
| Total interest | $5,230.41 | $7,043.97 | $6,032.37 |
| Origination fee | $0.00 | $0.00 | $525.00 |
| Total paid | $22,730.41 | $24,543.97 | $24,057.37 |
- Avalanche payoff order:
- Debt 2 (month 33), Debt 1 (month 34), Debt 3 (month 40)
- Snowball payoff order:
- Debt 1 (month 10), Debt 3 (month 24), Debt 2 (month 43)
Both orders use the same monthly budget of $575.00 (all minimums plus the extra amount). The consolidation loan has its own level payment. Arithmetic only: the table does not rank the three.
How the debt payoff calculator works, step by step
- Interest each month on each debt = balance × APR ÷ 12, rounded to the cent and added to the balance.
- Monthly budget = the sum of all minimum payments + the extra amount. For the example debts that is $575.00, and it stays the same until every debt is paid, so when a debt is paid off its minimum payment is added to the payment on the debts that are left.
- Each debt first receives its own minimum payment. The rest of the budget goes to one debt at a time. Avalanche: the debt with the highest APR first (the smaller starting balance first on a tie). Snowball: the debt with the smallest starting balance first (the higher APR first on a tie).
- Repeat month after month until every balance is $0. Months to payoff is the month the last balance reaches $0, and total interest is every month’s interest added together.
- A payment that does not exceed the monthly interest never pays down the balance. For the example debts, the first month’s interest is $254.17 against a monthly budget of $575.00. The calculator reports that the balance never pays down only when the whole budget does not exceed the monthly interest the total balance earns at the lowest APR, because then every month’s interest is at least the payment. Otherwise it simulates each order, since paying a high-APR debt first can lower later interest, and it reports a debt that is not paid off within 1,200 months.
- Consolidation: loan amount = total balance + origination fee (fee % × total balance, added to the loan). Monthly payment = loan × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), where r = APR ÷ 12 and n = months. Total paid comes from the unrounded monthly payment times n, so it can differ by a few cents from the displayed payment × n. For the example, the loan is $18,025.00 and the payment is $400.96.
Debt consolidation loan calculator: what the comparison shows
The consolidation column treats one new loan as paying off every balance you entered. The rate, term and fee are yours to enter; the calculator does not assume a rate. The CFPB describes what a consolidation loan does:
“These loans convert many of your debts into one loan payment, simplifying how many payments you have to make.”
A lower payment is not the same as a lower cost, because the term matters. The CFPB says:
“Although your monthly payment might be lower, it may be because you’re paying over a longer time. This could mean that you will pay a lot more overall, including fees or costs for the loan that you would not have had to pay if you continued making your other payments without consolidation.”
The CFPB also says of the rates on these loans:
“Many of the low interest rates for debt consolidation loans may be “teaser rates” that only last for a certain time. After that, your lender may increase the rate you have to pay.”
The calculator uses one fixed rate for the whole term, so it cannot show a rate that changes. It compares months, interest, any origination fee and total paid for the numbers you enter, and it does not rank the three columns.
Why results can differ from your statements
This calculator adds one month of interest at a time using the APR divided by 12. The CFPB describes interest on credit cards this way:
“Since interest is accruing daily, not monthly, this means that if you don’t have a grace period, the sooner you pay off all or some of your balance, the less interest you will pay.”
It also assumes the APRs stay fixed, nothing new is charged to any debt, and the monthly budget stays the same until every debt is paid. Late fees, balance transfer fees and promotional rates are not modeled.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the avalanche and snowball orders?
They differ only in which debt receives the money left after every minimum payment is made. In the avalanche order it goes to the debt with the highest APR first. In the snowball order it goes to the debt with the smallest starting balance first. This calculator runs both with the same monthly budget and shows the months and total interest each produces for your numbers. It does not recommend either order.
Why does the calculator say a balance never pays down?
Each month the interest is added to the balance before the payment is applied. If the payment does not exceed that month’s interest, the balance stays the same or grows, so it never reaches $0. The calculator stops with that message only when the total monthly budget does not exceed the interest the whole balance earns at the lowest APR, since then every month’s interest is at least the payment. In other cases it simulates the payoff, because paying a high-APR debt first can lower later interest, and it lists any single debt whose minimum payment does not exceed its own interest.
How does the consolidation loan comparison work?
It treats the consolidation as one new loan for your total balance plus an optional origination fee, with the APR and term you enter. This calculator adds the fee to the loan amount. The payment is the standard level payment, so the comparison shows its monthly payment, months, interest and fee next to the two payoff orders. The calculator does not assume any rate; the rate and fee are yours to enter, and a rate you are offered can differ from the example.
Will the results match my statements?
They can differ. This calculator adds one month of interest at a time using APR ÷ 12, while the CFPB passage on this page describes interest accruing daily, not monthly. It also assumes fixed APRs, no new charges, no late fees and the same monthly budget until every debt is paid. Treat the result as an estimate of the arithmetic, not a payoff quote.